WeatherZine #8

eZine lover (@eZine)

Published in

WeatherZine

· 11 months ago

WeatherZine #8
Number 8, February 1998

"What's happening on the Societal Aspects of Weather WWW Site."

WeatherZine is a bi-monthly on-line and e-mail distribution newsletter for the Societal Aspects of Weather Site. It contains a summary of recent changes to the site (along with links to relevant sections), and news, events, and announcements of interest to the community.

WeatherZine, and its parent WWW site, accept and encourage the submission of activities, events, or links of interest to the community. You can use the on-line forms in the Feedback section or can send an email to thunder@ucar.edu with the item you would like to see posted on the site or included in the next issue of the Zine.

[1] Editorial -- What is a Good Forecast?

With tragedies occurring in California and Florida in recent days and weeks, extreme weather has captured the attention of the nation. One result of these events will likely be to focus attention on how prepared we as a nation are to respond to floods, tornadoes, and other phenomena.

One question that will certainly be asked is how good were the forecasts? But a problem exists in answering this question: while the weather community has developed highly sophisticated methods for evaluation and verification of parts of the forecast process, it has not placed similar attention on evaluation of the process as a whole. As a consequence, typically when the weather community answers the question posed in the title of this editorial, the answers do not necessarily address what policy makers (and society more generally) considers to be most important.

The forecast process can be thought of as three parallel processes: (1) a prediction process that provides information, (2) a communication process that shares information, and (3) a choice process that focuses on decision. It is not enough that the forecast process be judged as meeting the criteria of success within each of the three process. The three processes must also be working together in harmony.

An example might better illustrate the problem. Last April, extreme flooding occurred in North Dakota and Minnesota. A review of what happened shows that the flood predictions were arguably just as good as those issued in the past (in spite of heavy criticism), the flood forecasts were effectively communicated to the public, and decision makers made rational decisions based on the information that they had. So while one could make the case that the individual elements of the forecast process were successful on technical grounds, the process as a whole clearly broke down in significant ways in terms of societal outcomes. A review of the forecast process suggests that the information about forecast uncertainty needed by decision makers (which many may not have even known they needed!) was not addressed in the prediction process and thus not communicated. The forecast PROCESS broke down even though the parts might have been successful on their own terms.

One way to think about the forecast process is to compare it to a symphony. The player of each instrument requires considerable expertise. We might assess the ability of each by asking them to play scales or part of a score. But it would silly to conclude that the symphony was playing good music after evaluating each member individually. Instead, to make music the symphony must play together from the same score. Small errors in the collective effort will result in noise, not music. The forecast process is similar, while different players have different responsibilities, they must be in harmony for success to result.

The analogy raises some interesting questions about the forecast process. Who ought to evaluate the goodness of forecasts? Who is the conductor responsible to ensure that the players are in harmony? How well has the forecast process been performing, from a societal perspective? What can be done to improve the forecast process?

These questions are difficult to answer. But as society becomes more vulnerable to weather extremes through development and other factors, these questions will be raised more and more frequently. Will the weather community have answers?

- Roger A. Pielke, Jr.

[2] Community News -- An AMS Congressional Fellows Program

The American Meteorological Society and the University Corporation for Atmospheric Research are considering initiation of a congressional fellows program, akin to those run by prominent scientific societies like AAAS, APS, AGU, and GSA.

A congressional fellow is much like a post-doc. But instead of placing the scientists in a research setting, a congressional fellows program provides a way for a recent Ph.D. in the physical sciences to spend some time working in a staff position in Congress. This serves two important functions. First, it provides congressional staff access to bright, scientific minds which facilitates the transfer of knowledge into the policy process. Second, it gives the scientist a chance to better understand how policy actually works and the role that science plays in decision making.

Looking at the track record of past congressional fellows sponsored by the scientific societies results in an impressive list. While many have returned to successful research careers, others have chosen to remain in Washington. Some have risen to positions of considerable influence in the world of science policy - within Congress, the Office of Management and Budget, and the Executive Office of the President, among other places.

As society places more attention on the interface of science and decision making, the experiences provided by an congressional fellowship will be all the more valuable to future scientists who choose research or policy careers. The AMS congressional fellowship would represent an important milestone in better connecting the atmospheric sciences with societal needs.

[3] New Additions to the WWW Site:

Emergency Management

Emergency Management Education Network (http://www.unex.ucr.edu/EMEN/EMEN.html) EMEN - the Emergency Management Education Network - is a Web- based resource that addresses a broad range of issues regarding emergency management, including business continuity and disaster recovery. Developed by the University of California Extension, Riverside, which offers courses in these fields, EMEN offers in-depth information for interested laypersons as well as emergency management, business continuity, and disaster recovery professionals. It also provides links to information about what lessons have been learned from previous disasters, what approaches are being taken by various organizations to lessen the impact of disasters, and ideas for the future from academia, professionals, and the public-at-large.
City of Fort Collins, CO, Office of Emergency Management (http://www.ci.fort-collins.co.us/C_SAFETY/oem/index.htm)
PERI (Public Entity Risk Institute)(http://www.riskinstitute.org) This is the Web site of the recently established Public Entity Risk Institute, an organization who's mission is to serve public, private, and nonprofit organizations as a resource for the practical enhancement of risk management - including risks associated with natural hazards. PERI is charged with serving the interests of public-sector organizations as well as small nonprofit organizations and businesses. The Web site includes extensive information about the organization, its plans and programs, as well as links to other useful risk information on the Web.

Turning Point Group Inc. (http://www.turningpointgroup.com) An emergency management product and service company in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, recently announced that it had established "Canada's first fully accessible bulletin board, focusing on the complete range of emergency management topics." The bulletin board, at the URL above, is intended to cover any topic related to emergency management: emergency preparedness, disaster response, and business recovery. It is open to anyone interested in the field. The Web site is a forum for dialogue and exchange of ideas among emergency practitioners from across Canada and the world and will be managed by three members of Turning Point Group Inc., all of whom have extensive experience in emergency management.

Mitigation.com (http://www.mitigation.com) The www.mitigation.com Web site is still under construction, but the creators intend to include sections on news, articles and editorials, resources, discussion boards, listserves, and employment.

Division of Emergency Management (http://www.state.fl.us/comaff/DEM) The Division of Emergency Management is tasked by the Florida legislature to direct the state's programs to plan for and respond to natural or technological disasters.

Flood

Association of State Floodplain Managers (http://www.floods.org/) The Association of State Floodplain Managers is an organization of professionals involved in floodplain management, flood hazard mitigation, the National Flood Insurance Program, and flood preparedness, warning and recovery. The group has become a respected voice in floodplain management practice and policy in the United States because it represents the flood hazard specialists of local, state and federal government, the research community, the insurance industry, and the fields of engineering, hydrologic forecasting, emergency response, water resources, and others.
Water Science and Technology Board (WSTB) (http://www2.nas.edu/wstb/) The site of the National Research Council's Water Science and Technology Board (WSTB) provides the mission statement of the board, information about current and past projects - many of which deal with flooding and other water-related hazards, and on-line reports and other publications. The site also includes the WSTB Newsletter, with current project updates and contact information.

The City of Fort Collins Flood (http://www.ci.fort-collins.co.us/C_SAFETY/DISPATCH/pfa3.htm) An insight on the devastating flood that took place in Fort Collins Colorado during July 1997.

[4] Subscribe Now!

The WeatherZine is produced as a Web site and an email message. Subscribing to the WeatherZine will add you to our distribution list and you will receive email messages whenever the WeatherZine is released.

To subscribe to the WeatherZine, use the on-line form at: www.esig.ucar.edu/socasp/forms/join.html, send an email to thunder@ucar.edu and include the following information:

Name
Organization
Email Address
Interests & Needs

or send an email to majordomo@ucar.edu and in the body of the message include:

subscribe weatherzine <your email address>

* do not include the <>'s. Majordomo will ignore the subject line.

For additional information, please contact thunder@ucar.edu

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Weather Impacts Group
Societal Aspects of Weather
Environmental and Societal Impacts Group
National Center for Atmospheric Research
US Weather Research Program

Societal Aspects of Weather Web Site: www.esig.ucar.edu/socasp/
WeatherZine: www.esig.ucar.edu/socasp/zine/